Bully Sticks Direct Reviews

Bully Sticks Direct has an overall rating of 3.9 based on 24 reviews. Customer feedback on Bully Sticks Direct is mixed.

3.9/5.0

24 reviews

5 Stars

10

4 Stars

3

3 Stars

10

2 Stars

1

1 Star

0

All Bully Sticks Direct Reviews (24)
TinaMills_48
May 27, 2026
"I grabbed this mainly for the..."
I grabbed this mainly for the bulk pricing, and yeah, it’s absolutely decent for that. I’m completely sure it’s not some amazing unbeatable deal, but it’s fine enough if you just need to stock up. Could 100% be a bit cheaper, though
david_Hansen98
May 25, 2026
"Why is delivery so random??"
The delivery is kind of all over the place. Sometimes it shows up super fast and I’m like, great?? But other times I’m sitting there waiting way longer than I expected. Not terrible, just really hit or miss.
AmandaHenry
May 02, 2026
"Doesn’t feel like the same quality"
I don’t know, these just didn’t feel as good as they used to. Right away, I got the sense something was off, the sticks were really dry and kind of splintery, like they might break or snag when using them. Not the quality I remember.
Harriet-locks
May 02, 2026
"Good chews, but I wish the sourcing was more upfront"
I’ve ordered from Bully Sticks Direct a couple of times now, and overall it’s been a decent experience. My dog is biased because he’ll happily chew on almost anything, but he really does seem to like these, and they’ve kept him busy. Shipping was about what I expected, and I didn’t have any issues with the orders themselves.

That said, I’m probably a little picky when it comes to dog treats, and I really wish they gave clearer details about where the bully sticks are sourced and how they’re processed. There is some information on the site, but to me it still feels a bit vague. I don’t think they’re a bad company at all, I’d just feel better ordering more often if the sourcing info was easier to find and more specific.
Martin.macneil
May 01, 2026
"I’m kind of picky about dog treats..."
I’m kind of picky about dog treats, but also not trying to overthink everything, so these seemed like a good middle ground. The ingredient list looks super plain, which I like, basically just bully sticks, no weird extras that I noticed. My dog absolutely loves them, maybe too much honestly. I do wish they lasted a little longer, but at the same time I’m glad he enjoys them so much. Overall, good enough for me.
REIK
April 22, 2026
"My dog was only kind of into them"
My dog chewed on them for a bit, but he lost interest quickly. They’re not terrible or anything, just definitely not his favorite treat. I also wish it was clearer what the next step is supposed to be if your dog doesn’t really take to them, like whether to try a different size, flavor, or just move on. Overall, they were okay, but I probably wouldn’t rush to buy them again.
DawnStavros_23
April 18, 2026
"Good sticks, but wow... the smell"
My dog is definitely a fan of these bully sticks, and they keep him occupied for a good while... so on that part, no complaints at all. Shipping was smooth too, which I appreciated.
The only downside is the smell. I know bully sticks aren’t exactly odor-free, but these were stronger than I expected once they were in the house. I might buy them again, but probably only for outside chewing...
SUOMELA
April 04, 2026
"Always fresh, and my dog is obsessed!"
My dog seriously loses his mind over these... in the best way. The bully sticks smell fresh, not stale or funky like some others I’ve tried before, and they don’t show up all dried out and crumbly either. Shipping was totally fine too, no issues there. Overall, I’m happy with the quality so far!
hello_thelma199
March 22, 2026
"Everything showed up exactly how I ordered..."
Everything showed up exactly how I ordered it, no mix-ups at all. The size and quantity were right, and it was packed up fine too. I weirdly remember the box having one little corner dent that looked like a tiny triangle, but nothing inside was damaged. can't ask for much more than that.
todd_Pereira94
March 22, 2026
"Plenty to choose from"
Lots of options here. Nice mix. Easy to find something I liked
CAPPS
March 14, 2026
"Dog liked them, but his stomach had opinions"
My dog was definitely into these and ate them right up, so no complaints there. But afterward his stomach seemed a little iffy, nothing dramatic, just kind of mixed results digestion-wise. It reminded me of when I try a new snack and then wonder why I didn’t just stick with what I know. Anyway, they’re not bad, but I’m not totally sure they’re the best fit for him.
carmen_Lancaster00
March 10, 2026
"I’ve ordered these twice now, and the..."
I’ve ordered these twice now, and the bully sticks have been pretty much the same thickness both times. i don’t have the patience to sort through a bag and figure out which ones are tiny and which ones are huge, so this makes things way easier. My dog gets a fair-sized chew every time
Mayra.baxter
March 09, 2026
"Showed up faster than I expected"
It got here quick, honestly. I think I ordered it while making coffee one morning, and then it was at my door before I really had time to wonder where it was. No complaints on the shipping at all.
SUTTON
March 01, 2026
"Feel good giving these to my dog"
These have no weird smell, and my dog chews them without any issues. A friend recommended them to me, and I’m glad I gave them a try because I feel safe giving them to my pup.
RichardLysiak
February 24, 2026
"My lab usually destroys chews in..."
My lab usually destroys chews in no time, but the ones I got from Bully Sticks Direct actually kept him occupied for a while. I finally got a little quiet time, which almost never happens around here.

They also didn’t smell nearly as bad as some others we’ve tried, so that was a nice surprise. Shipping was okay and the bag was packed well, though there was a small mix-up with the timing that I think deserved a quick apology. Still, I’ll probably order again once these are gone.
virginia_Gray02
January 31, 2026
"It seemed to work fine at..."
It seemed to work fine at first, but the weird part is it left residue all over my rug afterward. I wasn’t expecting to have to clean up that much after using it, so it was a little frustrating.
hello_ashley769
January 16, 2026
"Good savings, but instructions could be clearer"
I got a decent deal once the discount kicked in, and the coupons worked fine in the end. It saved me a bit on my order, which was nice. I just wish the instructions were a little clearer so I didn’t have to double-check how to apply everything
sophiemirr0609
January 04, 2026
"Finally, a site that didn’t make ordering a hassle"
I was expecting the usual online shopping headache, because somehow I always end up on sites that make simple stuff harder than it needs to be. But Bully Sticks Direct was actually really easy to use, and I found the bully sticks I wanted quickly without feeling like I had to dig around forever.
Checkout was smooth too, which was a relief because that’s usually where things go wrong for me. It didn’t keep pushing extra steps or random add-ons, and everything loaded fine on my phone, so for once I didn’t feel like the website was working against me.
richard1982
January 01, 2026
"Sizing feels a bit hit or miss"
I just assumed the sticks would all be close in size, because that’s usually what you expect, but a few were noticeably different. Not a huge deal, just kind of random
thomashughes6720
December 30, 2025
"I ordered from bullysticksdirect.com and ended up having..."
I ordered from bullysticksdirect.com and ended up having to reach out to customer service about my shipment. They did get back to me and were polite enough, but it definitely took a bit longer than I thought it would. The issue was fixed in the end, so I wouldn’t say it was a bad experience, just not the fastest. I’d maybe order again, but probably only if I wasn’t in a hurry.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Bully Sticks Direct?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.